Hi! I actually deleted the whole intro paragraph to this post just to respect your time and attention. It was too long. I've been collecting these for only a few months. Overall I think fountain pens might not be for me? Or maybe I'm buying too low quality? Or I'm doing something wrong? I hope I can get some advice. Thanks for reading (you can make fun of me and tell me I don't know what I'm doing, totally acceptable)
Notebooks tested on:
Mnemosyne (80gm)
Sakura Notebook (150gm)
Mosbull A5 (100gm)
- The Hong Dian Black Forest (Fine Nib) with Hong Dian ink, converter – writes very finely, very clear lines, medium scratchiness. I understand the scratchiness is because of the finer nib. This pen has "cut out" on me probably the most of all, though, even after a rinsing/flushing. This one actually feels the nicest to me in the hand.
- Beiluner (Extra fine Nib) with Beiluner cartridge – writes very finely, very clear lines, very consistent, but its like dragging a rake across concrete. I can't get it to "move", it doesn't feel smooth or buttery at all. Purchase regretted immediately. Feels only OK in the hand. Also, I feel like it's so thin that if I held it between the grooves of a vinyl record, the pen would play the song?
- Pilot Kakuno (Extra fine nib) with Pilot IC-50 cartridge – writes very finely, very clear lines, but is very dry feeling, does not "glide", hard to get it to "move". I pretty much want a pen that feels like I'm scooting 100 degree Farenheit stick of butter across solid glass. Also I mostly can't get it to actually write? "Drops out" like it had bad grades and a drug problem, issues at home, etc. Feels great in the hand though.
- Pilot Varsity (Medium nib) disposable no cartridge or converter – writes THE SMOOTHEST, I repeat IRREFUTABLY the smoothest of any pen I've ever used, but it spills so much fucking ink that my anti-legibility, anti-sensemaking handwriting become like egyptian hieroglyphics, most letters and words just look like I inhaled ink through a straw, and then sneezed on the page. Feels cheap and terrible in the hand, but damn is it smooth
- Hong Dian M2 (Fine Nib) converter with Hong Dian Ink – this is MY FAVORITE FOUNTAIN PEN, even though I still consider it to be pretty iffy on almost every surface i've tried it on. It writes "wet", its consistent, it has never dropped out on me, it writes at a perfect thickness, and it slides across the page like an ice skate. Keep in mind I didn't say "glide", I said it "slides", like an ice skate. Preferably it would "glide" like 100 degree butter across solid glass. Feels amazing in the hand.
- Pilot Writive (Fine Point) with Pilot IC-50 cartridge – Pretty much the same experience as the Kakuno, except it cuts out even more, it's scratchy and not buttery, and it feels very cheap.
- LEMY Vista (medium Nib) with LEMY cartridge – Now, THIS is the one that actually made me want to make this post. It surprised me. It doesn't feel scratchy, since it is a medium nib, but it feels extremely, and I mean extremely DRY. It is the most "dry" feeling of all the fountain pens I have bought. It is like nails on a chalkboard multiplied by 100,000. I actually almost threw it across the room after writing a paragraph with it because of the nails-on-chalkboard, raking a spoon across cardboard feeling.
Anyway, thanks for reading! Feel free to make fun of me, I don't care. I'm sure I'm doing something wrong. Just trying out a new hobby. I'm in my 40s etc. Other milennials will understand
https://i.redd.it/w9nry40y7yoh1.jpeg
Source: r/fountainpens · by /u/c_y_g_nus
